INDEPENDENT THINKING. WHOLE-FOOD LIVING.NO ANIMALS / NO OIL
THENANODIET
← Cardiology / Health Desk

The Portfolio diet tests a combination, not a champion food

A six-month trial separates a coordinated LDL-lowering pattern from claims about individual ingredients.

Whole-food ingredients prepared without added oil

Illustrative food image, not a photograph of the study intervention.

What was actually assigned?

Jenkins and colleagues’ 2011 randomized trial asked a practical question: could a combination of foods lower LDL when people selected their own meals? The investigators enrolled 351 adults with hyperlipidemia at four Canadian centers. They compared advice about a low-saturated-fat therapeutic diet with advice about a Portfolio pattern emphasizing plant sterols, soy protein, viscous fibers and nuts. This was not a comparison between one celebrated ingredient and an otherwise identical menu. The assigned exposure was a coordinated dietary strategy, including counseling about how to follow it.

David J A Jenkins, Peter J H Jones, Benoit Lamarche, Cyril W C Kendall et al.. JAMA, 2011. PMID 21862744 · DOI

Read the changes against the control.

After six months, reported LDL reductions were 13.8% with intensive Portfolio counseling and 13.1% with routine counseling, compared with 3.0% in the control group. Those percentages describe changes within each group, not a 13-percentage-point advantage over the comparison diet. Both Portfolio groups performed significantly better than control. The two counseling intensities did not differ significantly from each other. That result supports the tested pattern under these conditions; it does not establish that additional appointments can never help an individual or that counseling intensity is irrelevant in other settings.

David J A Jenkins, Peter J H Jones, Benoit Lamarche, Cyril W C Kendall et al.. JAMA, 2011. PMID 21862744 · DOI

The broader trial evidence is still about LDL.

Chiavaroli and colleagues’ 2018 systematic review included seven controlled trial comparisons involving 439 participants with hyperlipidemia. Against an energy-matched comparison diet, the Portfolio pattern produced an approximately 17% LDL reduction, with a pooled difference of −0.73 mmol/L. The review also reported a reduction in estimated ten-year coronary risk. Estimated risk is a calculation, however, not an observed count of prevented heart attacks. Its inclusion does not turn these risk-factor trials into cardiovascular event trials, nor does the pooled result promise the same response for every participant.

Laura Chiavaroli, Stephanie K Nishi, Tauseef A Khan, Catherine R Braunstein et al.. Progress in cardiovascular diseases, 2018. PMID 29807048 · DOI

Why the pattern cannot award ingredient medals.

The six-month experiment changed several dietary targets together. Its design therefore cannot tell us how much of the LDL difference belonged to nuts rather than soy or viscous fiber, or whether a specific combination was synergistic. Better adherence was associated with larger LDL reductions among Portfolio participants, but adherence itself was not randomly assigned. In the kitchen, use the study as a reason to think in terms of an overall pattern rather than a single garnish. A bowl assembled at home is not automatically the tested intervention, and these results provide no basis for replacing prescribed treatment.

David J A Jenkins, Peter J H Jones, Benoit Lamarche, Cyril W C Kendall et al.. JAMA, 2011. PMID 21862744 · DOI